Logging Makes Forests More Flammable: Study

Thursday, 11 February 2010

Dani Cooper ABC

According to the researchers, logging has shifted the composition of moist forests to resemble drier, more fire prone ones

Commercial logging of moist native forests creates conditions that increase the severity and frequency of bushfires, an international study claims.

The finding by Australian, Canadian and US researchers is based on a review of previous studies and is published in the latest issue of the journal Conservation Letters.

Professor David Lindenmayer of the Fenner School of the Environment and Society at the Australian National University, says the team focused on how industrial logging practices in native forests might change fire loads, fire frequency and susceptibility to ignition.

"The evidence from rainforests is unequivocal, the evidence from the wet forests in North America is unequivocal and the evidence is starting to build in Australia as well. When you mess with [native wet] forests they become more flammable."

The researchers found the removal of trees by logging creates canopy openings and this in turn alters microclimatic conditions, especially increased drying of understory vegetation and the forest floor, Lindenmayer says.

"Work in tropical rainforests suggests that when microclimatic conditions are altered by selective logging, the number of dry days needed to make a forest combustible is reduced," he says.

In one study, uncut native forest would generally not burn after less than 30 rainless days but selectively logged forest would burn after just six to eight days without rain.

Their finding throws doubt on calls by some politicians and the National Association of Forest Industries to log forests to prevent major wildfires, made in the wake of the 2009 Black Saturday wildfires, which claimed 173 lives in southeastern Australia.

Changing density

He says logging also influences the fire regime by changing the density and pattern of trees, altering the spacing between tree crowns and the composition of plants.

According to Lindenmayer, logging in the moist eucalypt forests of East Gippsland in southeastern Australia "has shifted the vegetation composition toward one more characteristic of drier forests that tend to be more fire prone".

He says clear-felling of moist forests in southern Australia can create more fire fuel because it leads to the development of dense stands of regrowth saplings.

Lindenmayer says these young forests are more flammable, which often lead to older, less flammable forests abutting them to burn.

He adds, logging slash - the debris left by logging - can also sustain fires for longer than fuels in unlogged forests and can harbour fires when wind conditions are not suitable to spread the blaze.

Lindenmayer says the industry needs to think strategically about where they log and rethink buffer zones and how big they might need to be.

For example he points to the Ponderosa pine forests in the US which are now being thinned to restore tree distribution to its more natural state as a way of reducing fire risk.

He says these forests became more dense and had a higher fire risk after the native bison, which used to roam through the forest creating large gaps between trees, were decimated.

Source: ABC Science News